Vienna: The Housing World We Have Lost

Vienna is a city of two million people, of which nearly 60% live in affordable housing – a mixture of municipal housing owned by the city and subsidised housing managed by 54 different limited profit companies. Only about 20% of residents own their own homes, and in the private sector properties over 30 years old have controlled rents. Only a small proportion of the richer population rent in the newer unrestricted private sector. The institutional and economic infrastructure that makes this possible was built up over the past 100 years and has been made easier because social democrats have run the city government since democracy was introduced. Land can be assembled by a public land company, new build happens through public development corporations, and the city has a powerful zoning system that ensures new subsidised housing is built – if the site is more than 5000 square metres, two thirds has to be for affordable housing. Because of the scale of social housing, it is not just for the very poor, but for everyone: there are allocation criteria but they are light, housing can be allocated to those over 18, who have lived in Vienna for two years, and with a maximum income at the start of the tenancy (but never re-assessed during the tenancy) of around 100,00 euros per person. A new system is being introduced to add bonus points for people with special needs, single parents, people about to become homeless, people over 65 etc. The quality of housing is fiercely maintained by the city, with architectural competitions, strong environmental and ecological standards, and encouragement for innovation and creativity. Much of the housing has greenery, communal spaces, roof saunas and gardens, shared play areas, etc. The funding comes from the resources the city has built up over a century of building housing and receiving rental payments – and from some housing-linked taxation. The city can give interest free loans to limited profit companies for social housing, and when loans are repaid, housing rents are reduced. 

I was lucky enough to see some of this for myself in a study tour organised by the Friedrich Ebert Foundation, to which Compass was invited. And as I walked round the well-kept well-maintained modern housing, I felt a real sadness for the housing world that we in the UK have lost, one in which social housing did not carry a stigma, in which housing estates were not the homes only of desperate, vulnerable, impoverished people, where people could easily self-organise and were encouraged to look after each other, and where home ownership was not an unrealisable symbol of a security out of reach for many.  

Of course Vienna still has its problems. But as we spoke to city councillors, academics, tenant leaders, civil society organisations about the problems they still face – the advent of Air BnB, the rapid growth of population, the difficulties of enforcing rent controls, the shift, over time, to more and more private development – these problems still felt manageable, because of the strong institutional and civil society framework of laws, organisations and social values. 

In the UK, in contrast,  we have dismantled much of the social and economic infrastructure that supported our social housing. We too, once created social housing that was high quality and housed a fair proportion of ordinary working people. At its peak, UK social housing housed 30% of the population. We had building quality standards that were higher than those in the private sector, and in the 1960s and 70s, rent controls were introduced that protected most private sector tenants. Housing associations were established in the 1970s that offered a range of subsidised housing options and could develop housing as well as manage it. Local authorities had large departments of  architects, planners and experts, capable of assembling land, developing housing and enforcing standards. Many people of my generation grew up in local authority housing. 

But we made some big mistakes.  The rush to build municipal housing led to the development of vast housing estates, often poorly constructed using new materials and techniques which led to problems of damp and condensation. Brutalist designs often led to estates that were hard to live in, sometimes out of town with poor transport, or few shops, built at a scale that erased local community. Allocation policies meant that only those with the greatest need would qualify, young people and middle-income people were excluded. Some estates became famous for drugs, crime and social collapse – some were eventually demolished and rebuilt at  more human scale. And by the 1980s home ownership had become the dream of many, encouraged by government, and affordable to ordinary working people. 

In 1979, the Thatcher government was elected with a new policy – selling council housing to the residents that lived in it, offering very generous discounts – a policy that represented a one-time transfer of wealth to working people. The policy was highly popular, but over the next couple of generations, it had a catastrophic effect on our housing. The best council housing, the houses with gardens, was disproportionately sold off, while even flats in large estates were sold, at first to tenants, and then sold on , often to private landlords that continued to rent them out at far higher rents. Housing Associations were forced to sell properties at discounts too, and were underfunded, and driven to build for market-rents in order to cross-subsidise what social housing they had left. Slowly, their commitment to social housing became dwarfed by managing large mixed property portfolios. Most councils transferred their remaining council housing to large housing associations and dismantled their housing departments. What social housing was left became the last resort for the most vulnerable: the homeless, immigrants, the elderly, people with disabilities, people with physical and mental illness, the people with the fewest resources and the lowest energy. And the money to maintain and improve social housing ebbed away. New build was by now disproportionately of owner-occupied housing and privately rented housing. Local councils could no longer afford to build. And while the dream of owner occupation remained a conservative mantra, the reality was slipping out of reach of most ordinary people. Meanwhile, the rent controls that protected private tenants were dismantled, and private sector rents began to rise and rise.  The outcome has been that many households, excluded from social housing and unable to afford to buy are dependent on a private rented sector that is all but unaffordable. In London, the poorest 30% of private renters are paying over 60% of their income on housing, and 70% of private renters were considered to be in poverty after paying their rent. The failure of benefit payments to match the actual rent paid, means that money that should be used for food and subsistence is paid to private landlords.  

So What Did I Learn in Vienna? 

Change will not happen fast. Reversing years of decline and neglect will take decades. There is no single ‘silver bullet’ policy that can achieve this. We need to patiently rebuild the infrastructure and not-for-profit institutions capable of sustaining good quality affordable housing. We have some of them still, but they are underfunded and lack capacity. We will need to recreate others from scratch. Vienna’s housing is the result of powerful and resilient public institutions, public resources accumulated through the right policies, effective regulation and enforcement, open-minded and creative politicians and strong citizen support. 

Land banking, zoning, development can all be run at local government level, where leaders  understand the city or region well to create carefully nuanced policies that fit the needs of the place. 

The design and management of housing can only really be planned and organised at a hyper-local level, on a relatively small scale with attention not just to homes,  but to transport, amenities, parks, schools, health facilities etc. If these things are thought through together, good housing results. In Vienna areas are carefully zoned so that social housing is built in the right places and private developers cannot create social monocultures.  

Social housing that is only for the poor won’t work. Nor will huge monolithic single tenure estates. There is a need for a choice of different sorts of affordable housing, including co-operatives, co-ownership, municipal housing and housing associations to go alongside home ownership and private renting.  There is a need for sufficient social housing to offer homes to young people starting out, people who’s lives are changing mid-life, people who prefer renting or who are changing direction – enough to end the sense of stigma and the pejorative labelling of social housing. 

At the city and sub-regional level, we need public control of planning and developing housing, with not-for-profit institutions planning for the long-term. 

The quality of new housing needs to be carefully controlled, ensuring good design and attention to detail – In Vienna architectural competitions are used to find the best possible design, and the city has a long tradition of sponsoring creativity and experimentation. More recently, attention has shifted to creating sustainable and environmentally sensitive developments, with attention to an environment good for people, animals and plants. Much has been achieved in designs that conserve and reduce energy use – but the unusual heat of the last two summers focusses attention on a new environmental priority – cooling! Many large housing blocks become ovens in the heat. Again, Vienna is in the forefront of thinking about how to introduce cooling measures to social housing. 

Rent controls are inoperable without both an effective system of enforcement and powerful civil society organisations able to publicise tenant’s rights and support them in legal action where necessary. In Vienna, we met leading figures from AK, Vienna’s hundred- year- old ‘Chamber of Labour’ an organisation set up in the days of ‘red Vienna’ to support workers. With four million members it is a formidable organisation, and its Department of Local Policy and Housing provides advice and legal support to tenants, checks rents are legal and takes hundreds of court cases  to enforce tenant’s rights, and advocates for improved legislation, based on experience.  

And lastly, our discussions with so many wise and experienced leaders in Vienna strengthened the belief I have always had, that good housing can only be created through collaboration between many different organisations, through seeing many different perspectives and through involving and listening to those who live in it.

A Plan for Housing in the UK

So here are my suggestions, based on learning from Vienna, for beginning the long process of creating an adequate supply of affordable good quality housing in the UK and changing millions of lives in the process. We did it once before. We could do it again. 

  1. Create an independent, not-for-profit Housing Investment Bank with a remit to invest in high-quality social housing projects. Housing investment should not need to be included in the PSBR, since it is supported by an income stream that can repay loans over time. 
  2. Create arrangements for public land banks at city and regional level, able to make preferential arrangements to supply land for social and affordable housing. 
  3. Give Mayoral and city authorities stronger powers to zone land for different sorts of development, including zoning areas for affordable housing, amenities etc. 
  4. Create public development corporations – some could grow from existing housing associations with development arms, others might be developed by city, regional or local governments.  
  5. Re-set the remit of housing associations to meet social housing needs and provide affordable housing and offer additional investment funding to those with charitable or not-for-profit status and public service values. 
  6. Strengthen the role of local authorities in ensuring quality in all new build housing, including measures to ensure housing is sustainable in the context of climate change. Ensure that regulations can be flexed at local level to ensure sensible decisions are made. 
  7. Plan and design additional social housing in small scale developments, drawing on a wide range of not-for-profit providers and ensuring access can be extended to young people and those on middle-incomes. Plan new developments through collaboration between government and civil society organisations responsible for social care and health, housing, employment, transport and a sustainable environment. 
  8. Introduce moderate rent controls in the private sector, concentrating on reducing rent increases beyond inflation, with exemptions where needed, and with an effective system of assessment and enforcement. The Joseph Rowntree Foundation suggests tax changes including mortgage tax relief to small landlords to protect them from unexpected costs such as interest rate rises. 
  9. Enable local authorities to buy properties from landlords wishing to exit the market, to sustain the level of rented housing. 
  10. Fund local organisations such as CAB to inform tenants of their rights, offer advice and support them in legal action when needed.
  11. Ensure tenant and service user representation in all the organisations responsible for housing policy and ensure that their voice is heard at national level. Create a social institution to identify and share best practice in housing policy – working with governments, housing associations, tenant and community organisations. 

Sue Goss is a coach, strategic advisor and facilitator to leadership teams in local government, the civil service and the health service.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Compass started
for a better society
Join us today